Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dana Ames's avatar

Richard, you wrote: "This notion--channels of sacred energy structuring and flowing through the cosmos--isn't common to Christianity." Well, actually it is known in Orthodoxy. We start our personal prayers and many church services with "O heavenly king, the comforter, the Spirit of Truth, who art everywhere present and filling all things..." The Holy Spirit is energetic and does a lot of work here! St Maximos, whom I know you know, speaks of the Logos infusing all aspects of creation with logoi, their own "principles", so to speak, all tied in to Christ in his capacity as the Second Person of the Trinity and the Person through whom creation was accomplished (by the energy of the Holy Spirit). This was known and discussed and virtually agreed upon in the stream of Apostolic Christianity before AD 800 or so.

Kabbalah arose much later, after the completion of the Masoretic text and solidification of Rabbinic Judaism; perhaps it is a bit of a reaction to it. Or it may be that it sort of runs parallel to Christian gnosticism but gained strength rather than faded into the background and away from little-o orthodoxy, as the Christian gnostics did.

There are plenty of mystical connections to Judaism in early Christianity; they're recognized by Christian scholars, esp those who study the Christian Syriac tradition. Bishop Alexander (Golitzin) in the OCA Diocese of the South is just such a scholar, and world-renowned. He taught at Marquette for many years. One of his graduate students started and maintains a web site with many resources for anyone interested: https://www.marquette.edu/maqom/

The vast majority of Protestants who want a more enchanted form of Christianity turn to Kabbalah or Gurdjieff or (better, at least ) the Western mystics of the late middle ages (Julian of Norwich, Teresa of Avila, John of the Cross, the Beguines) or what they believe is Celtic Christianity. To me, this speaks of the dryness of (mostly) Evangelicalism. They don't realize that the unified Chrisitianity of pre-800 AD or so already has what they want, and it continues in EO (and probably with the Ethiopians as well).

Dana

Expand full comment
Cercatore's avatar

As most know, ‘Gematria’ is a forest of esoteric exploration. Rabbi Mark Wildes (of MJE fame) has a great short video entitled; “Is Gematria Legit or Just A Cheap Trick?” where he discusses the gist of the discipline with Rabbi Avraham Arieh Trugman. Now, I really like these guys and have a tremendous respect for them, their faith and their abstruse beliefs and convictions derived from gematric formulations. However…..like many (not so well intentioned) “Christian” prophetic cryptanalysts (deciphers), numerological approaches to scripture can at times, lead to erroneous predictions and outcomes. If one’s explorations lead to a kind of personal spiritual epiphany derived from beautifully hidden and concealed truths within the text, then you’re on the right path. On the flip side though, spurious correlations though can just as easily be derived from flexible numeric attributions that add up or multiply to whatever one subconsciously desires beforehand. In the video, Trugman’s ‘microscope analogy’ was excellent, logically coherent and made a lot of sense. But the skeptic within me is very cautious when presented pathways to ‘secret biblical knowledge’. I’ve seen too many people lost in the shadowy depths of that kind of rabbit hole labyrinth. Knowing [why I believe] [what I believe] is as inherently important as the [experience I’m having] in discovering that Truth.

Expand full comment

No posts